Question 1

Which has lower long-term cost — Ford Mustang Mach-E or Tesla Model Y?

Accepted Answer

Based on national-average assumptions, the Ford Mustang Mach-E is about $3,716 cheaper to own over 5 years. The breakdown includes depreciation, insurance, fuel or energy, maintenance, financing, and registration. Your localized total may differ based on state fuel prices, insurance rates, and EV registration fees.

Question 2

Which is cheaper to insure — Ford Mustang Mach-E or Tesla Model Y?

Accepted Answer

Insurance varies by state, ZIP code, age, and credit tier. Enter a ZIP to see a localized estimate; both vehicles' national-average premiums are shown on the compare page.

Question 3

Which depreciates faster — Ford Mustang Mach-E or Tesla Model Y?

Accepted Answer

Depreciation over the first five years is itemized in the cost breakdown. Luxury and EV models typically lose more value in early years; segment leaders and Toyota/Honda hold value better.

Question 4

Is the Ford Mustang Mach-E better than the Tesla Model Y?

Accepted Answer

It depends on how you drive. The compare page scores both vehicles across five pillars — cost of ownership, powertrain, driver assistance, livability, and safety — combined into one MotiveGrid Score, alongside a 5-year cost breakdown and a clear verdict. Pick the one whose strengths match how you actually use a car.

Question 5

Why do these two vehicles get different ADAS (driver-assist) scores?

Accepted Answer

Our ADAS scale weighs sensor stack (radar + camera vs camera-only), hands-free operating domain (highway vs any divided road), driver-monitoring quality (eye-tracking vs torque sensor), and whether the system gets OTA improvements. Two vehicles can advertise the same feature names and still score 20+ points apart once operating envelope and update cadence are accounted for.

Question 6

Why does EV depreciation differ from a comparable gas vehicle?

Accepted Answer

EV residuals follow a different curve for three reasons. Aggressive manufacturer price cuts and subsidized lease deals compress the used market — a new EV often transacts well below MSRP, dragging down used values. Battery state-of-health uncertainty creates a risk premium on used EVs. And fast-improving charging speed, range, and ADAS hardware make a 3-year-old EV feel older than a 3-year-old gas car.

Metric	Ford Mustang Mach-E	Tesla Model Y
MotiveGrid Score	78	76
Cost of Ownership	73	67
Powertrain	66	71
Driver Assistance	49	30
Livability	40	46
Safety	99	100
5-Year Cost to Own	$49,048	$52,764
Depreciation (5-yr)	$22,299	$25,034
Fuel / Energy (5-yr)	$4,412	$2,863
Insurance (5-yr)	$11,340	$14,260
Maintenance (5-yr)	$1,590	$1,125
Tires (5-yr)	$2,050	$1,750
Financing (5-yr)	$5,687	$6,017
Registration (5-yr)	$1,670	$1,715
Starting Price	$37,795	$39,990
Horsepower	264 hp	295 hp
Electric range	260 mi	321 mi
Cargo volume	29.7 cu ft	76 cu ft
Seating	5	5
Towing capacity	—	3,500 lbs
Drivetrain	RWD	RWD

Ford Mustang Mach-E vs. Tesla Model Y

Five measured pillars, weighted into one score.

Which vehicle is right for you

Cost of Ownership

Frequently asked questions

Where these rank

Helpful guides